
Few things trigger an instant, uncomfortable physiological reaction quite like feeling romantic jealousy surface in a relationship. Rather than viewing this intense emotion as a toxic flaw or proof of a failing partnership, what if it is actually an invitation to build deeper intimacy and trust? In this episode, relationship expert and author Ally Iseman breaks down the physiological, psychological, and sociological layers behind why we experience jealousy and how it serves as a crucial bid for connection. Author of the upcoming book For the Love of Jealousy, she introduces her proprietary Jealousy Growth Method—a practical six-step framework designed to turn emotional discomfort into personal development and relational growth. Tune in to discover how to distinguish intuition from insecurity, navigate modern digital triggers, and effectively repair trust after a rupture.
—
Watch the episode here
Listen to the podcast here
What Is It Really Trying To Tell You? With Ally Iseman
Unpacking The Physiology Of Romantic Jealousy
In this episode, we have Ally Iseman, and we talk about jealousy. What is it really trying to tell you? Men’s Anonymous.

Ally, so good to have you on the show.
Likewise, thank you for having me.
We are going to go into a topic which is very near and dear to you. He has actually become a bit of a domain expert in the space, which is the topic of jealousy. I want to start with something almost everyone tuning in will recognize. You are with someone you love, and another man starts talking to her. Maybe he is attractive. Maybe she is enjoying the attention. Suddenly, something happens inside of you.
Your stomach tightens. You have a shitty feeling, let us say. You are watching them. You are telling yourself you do not care. You absolutely, obviously do care. Something is happening to you inside. I want to ask you because most men I know have experienced something like that at some point. I am sure women experience it as well. I want to ask you what exactly is happening in that moment that I just described?
Many things are the short answer. First, I want to say thank you so much. I really appreciate you wearing a green shirt in honor of the green-eyed monster, as I call it, really on topic. I really love it. That is such a fantastic question. What is happening is a lot. There is a physiological element happening. There is a psychological element happening, and there is a sociological element happening. We say jealousy, which actually encompasses a lot of different things. What is happening physiologically, neurologically, is that the front left cortex of your brain is being activated.
That is the area of your brain responsible for what is called approach motivation. Moving towards something. This is why I come from the perspective that jealousy is actually a bid for connection. It is an opportunity to lean in and get vulnerable with your partner. It is inherently uncomfortable because vulnerability is inherently uncomfortable. That is what intimacy requires. What is happening is this flush of information. Most people are going straight to the story. We are going straight to the psychology of it. We are not even stopping in the body because it is so uncomfortable.
I do not want to be with that. I am just going to go into what this means. It is going to mean whatever society has told you it means, which is actually where my obsession with jealousy started. I noticed a very important contradiction that was happening. I have a private practice. I work with primarily couples, I do also work with individuals as well. What I saw with jealousy was these two big conflicting messages. Somehow, jealousy is simultaneously a bad thing. You are a bad person for feeling it. Something is wrong with you.
Something is wrong with the relationship. It is not a good thing. You do not want to be jealous. Also, as you actually said in your intro, it is also proof that you care. It is proof of love. How can those two things be true? What science shows us, what much research shows us, is that neither is actually inherently true. Jealousy is something that can occur whether you are in a secure or insecure relationship, whether you are a secure or insecure person. The difference is what we do with it.

That is fascinating. Everyone experiences it, effectively.
Everyone has the capacity to. Everyone has the capacity to.
I want to ask you. I have been reading a book called The Continuum Concept, which talks about how we are biologically pre-programmed as humans. The best way they have tried to capture this is that they have gone and studied a tribe within the jungle that is just within its own. The only society that exists is the tribal society. It is the best or the nearest example of how we behave without having any external factors that we experience in modern society impacting the way humans actually interact with each other in their purest form.
One of the observations in that Indigenous tribe setting was that jealousy was not something that was experienced there. It is not how we are. It is actually not how we are naturally pre-programmed. Yet in society, that is definitely not the case. People have that emotion of jealousy. Can you define for us what actually happened, because you broke down, said physiologically, psychologically, what was the third one?
Sociologically.
The Three Layers: Physiological, Psychological, And Sociological Factors
Can you break down for us, like, define, like, those three things going on? Can you walk us through those at a high level? What is going on in those three different segments?
What you are talking about is a really important component of it. The evolutionary model. There is the sociological model and the evolutionary model. There is a physiology that can happen. Again, it is when we are looking at behavioral psychology, it is more like, make retention strategies, resource guarding, stuff like that. Again, still within the structure of whatever social structure that you are in. What we also see from a sociological component is that, in modern societies around the world, jealousy is still treated differently, talked about differently, experienced differently.
We have the sociological understanding of what we are supposed to do if we feel this way. We call it jealousy. We decide what that means about us or our relationship, and now we apply that to the psychological story. Within us, based on our previous life experiences, based on how we show up in the world. What studies show us is that there are two groupings of jealousy. We will call it experiences of jealousy. They are reactive, responding to something that is currently happening and suspicious, building a story around what might be happening. Even if there are things certainly happening.
What we are telling ourselves.
Exactly, very much. Either way, I break down within those two, the four types, because what we also see is jealousy is not just inherently about the bond, about the relationship. It can also be about the self. What does this relationship mean about me? Is it a social status, that thing? More identity level? Within Romantic Jealousy, I break it down into four different types. I am actually like neck-deep in 111, 112 studies right now. Doing a meta-analysis at the same time as I am writing my first book. It is quite phenomenal to see what research actually shows us versus what we are being told. Some very important things.
As I said, is this about me or is this about the relationship? It’s a really important question. Being afraid of losing the relationship because of what it says about me or how it impacts my social standing and my social network, my value in the dating market, whatever that means is very different than this person, and I have built a life, and this loss, it is still the fear of loss. The meaning behind it is very different. Really figuring out which one is very important. Again, the reactive versus the suspicious is also very important. Is there actually stuff happening right now, or am I building a story?
It’s very important. We call them diagnostic questions. I hesitate to say diagnostic because it is something I also want to bring up when we are talking about this. I do not know if you have heard this with any of your audiences the idea of, like, I am not a jealous person, or I am a jealous person. As you just said. Our evolutionary model is not necessarily called jealousy. This idea that jealousy is a personality trait or a fixed point or like a whole identity is backed by nothing. Jealousy is an emotion that we have the capacity to feel. There may be, myself, I never actually experienced jealousy until I was well into my 30s.
This is something that is not inherently like, “If you are going to experience it, you experience it from childhood all the way through.” We have studies that show infants are experiencing what we call jealousy when it comes to their primary caregiver. Siblings are one. Also, the core primary caregiver showing attention to another infant can elicit what we label as jealousy. There is an evolutionary component. Again, what do we call it? How do we treat it? When it shows up. That is the difference between the evolutionary side and that.
From an evolutionary perspective, why do you think human beings were given the emotion of jealousy? What was the function of that from an evolutionary perspective, do you think?
The camp is, like I said, resource guarding, retention, that again, is very dependent on what culture it has come up in. A biological versus sociological. It is a very complex conversation. There are two camps of yes, this is an evolutionary trait that we have, as you can see in the infant studies, etc. We have the sociological, anthropological camp that is like, “No, look at these communities that are not modern, they are not, it is not, showing up the same way, etc.”
Those are actually two very loud oppositional camps in the research. I do include both. It is important to really, to really look at it. We have the context. We have the ability as humans, this wonderful, as far as we know, unique ability to have thoughts about our thoughts, to self-reflect, to observe ourselves. That is where my main thesis is that jealousy is actually that. It is information.
Jealousy is actually a bid for connection. It's an opportunity to lean in and get vulnerable with your partner. Share on XWhether it is evolutionary, sociological, whatever camp you are in, there is something there for you that can be very valuable when you are actually working with it versus letting it take over and run the show. That is the whole thesis of my book, which is called For the Love of Jealousy. It is making the case that, based on research data or my client work, again, pulling from the research I am in right now and then my own lived experience, jealousy is really the most misunderstood and underused emotion to deepen trust and intimacy in romantic relationships.
Envy Vs. Jealousy: Understanding The Fear Of Loss
Can I ask you, is there a difference between the jealousy that a man experiences versus the jealousy that a woman experiences?
Yes and no. Again, we have different types. Men and women, across the board, there is no difference in, like, potential intensity, frequency, anything like that. The studies that I am looking at do not change regardless of gender, regardless of, like I said, security or insecurity of self or the relationship structure. It occurs in all different types of relationships, monogamous, non-monogamous, what have you. The difference comes down to, as far as secure or insecure, how jealousy is used in the relationship, how it is approached.
The reactive versus the suspicious. When we address it directly, again, not from an accusatory space, “This is what is happening for me.” We can actually go through my work. I have developed what I call the jealousy growth method, which is how people can actually start building that relationship with jealousy, using it as a tool, I like to say, so it does not turn you into one. It takes over, and it really is running the show, and it shows up because I will say I am talking about this. When we are talking about this, I am super chill. Super chill.
That is not what it feels like when it is happening. I want to be real clear that this process is to help you get that activated state and start using it as something that is a part of your personal development and relational growth. It is built from, like I said, the biological, physiological, physical component of what jealousy is, what is happening in your body, psychological, what is happening in your mind. What is that connection, then, to the sociological as well? How to really integrate it.
Can I ask you, so you were talking about, is jealousy about something actually going on, or is there something about ourselves? I am going to speak from a man’s perspective, I have a partner, and I am in a serious relationship. That is a pretty standard example of what people are experiencing. If I am the man in that relationship, when I feel jealous, what am I actually afraid of? Am I afraid of losing her? Am I afraid of being humiliated? Am I afraid of being replaced? Am I afraid of discovering that somehow maybe I am not enough? What am I jealous of?
Potentially any of those things. Jealousy is the fear of loss. We use jealousy the same way we say, we say envy, we will say jealousy. It is important to understand the difference.
There is a difference there with envy. There is a difference.
It’s super important. Brené Brown actually talks about this in her work as well. Envy is pure desire. I want something I do not yet have, or I want to be the person who has the thing that I do not yet have. It is specifically wanting something that is not yours. Jealousy, on the other hand, is actually fear of losing something that you already have, a relationship, etc. I will use an example for the gents tuning in.
Envy is specifically wanting something that is not yours. Jealousy, on the other hand, is the fear of losing something that you already have. Share on XLet us say your neighbor buys your dream car. You have had this car. This is the car you get when you are successful, and you have made it. Now your neighbor has it, and it is sitting in the driveway next to you every day. You have to see it as you are going to work. It is there like, “Man, I want that car. I want to be my neighbor because they have that car.” That is envy.
That is when they say you are green with envy.
Exactly. You are envious. You want that car. Now that neighbor, who is the symbol of success, by your definition, because they have that car, is going to take your long-term girlfriend, your wife, for a ride around the block in this new car. You are afraid that maybe they might not come back, or maybe something a little more than just a ride around.
You are jealous.
The Green-Eyed Gaze: Navigating Shame, Blame, And Denial
Now we are jealous. A very important difference. Something you already have, or someone should say that is already within your life the fear of losing them. Everything you just listed. What does this say about me? Everything that is coming up, am I enough? These are all the potential data points that we have for our personal and relational growth when we actually start working with jealousy. Instead of flying into what I call the green-eyed gaze, which is one of three ways that we generally direct jealousy when it comes up rather than actually working with it. If it is the green-eyed monster, the green-eyed gaze, we either turn inwards with shame. I am a bad person.
I should not be feeling like this. Of course they do not want to be with me. This should not be coming up. There is something wrong with me. There is something wrong with the relationship, whatever it is. Poor me, or we direct it out with blame at our partner. You are making me feel this way. You should not be doing this. You need to change your behavior. You are responsible for making me feel better. We are taking that discomfort, and we are throwing it onto somebody else so we do not have to deal with it. Feel it at all, or the third option, just close our eyes entirely, and we are in complete denial. I am not a jealous person. I do not feel jealousy.
That is not something that comes up. I have evolved. I am above that because jealousy is bad. That does not. None of those make it go away. I can assure you if you are using any of those to avoid the actual process of jealousy, it will come up, and it will come up in the most destructive, inconvenient way possible. The green-eyed gaze is what we generally do. We do it again. We direct it inward in a self-abusive and shameful way. We direct it outward with blame, or we just deny it entirely. None of that is working with jealousy to actually find out what is going on.
The process that I created, the jealousy growth method, is a six-step process, GROWTH, that helps people actually sit in jealousy, discover what it is telling them, and learn how to communicate that with their partner. Even if it is telling you something, actually, let us use an example. I think you said that not enough can be a big one. Like, “I am not fill in the blank, successful enough, funny enough, rich enough, whatever it is. Fit enough.” That is data. I would be really careful with what I am saying right here. It can be data like, “Actually, this is important to me. I want to feel healthier. I want to feel more active so that I do not feel that lack of enoughness.”
Not for my partner’s approval. That is a very different thing. Like, “I now know I do not feel fit enough, like happy enough,” whatever the enoughness is to you. That is valuable information. It is very different from my partner being emotionally abusive about that thing. That is not what we are talking about here. “I have information. I actually want to work on this so that I feel better and I feel enough for myself in that. I want to communicate to my partner what is going on.”
It is not their responsibility to change that for me. “This is what is happening for me. This is what I am doing about it.” I could use some extra words of affection. Can you remind me that you think I have a tight ass? Whatever that looks like for you, like, can we flirt more? Can we cuddle more often? Can I get some more physical affection when we are walking around to support that connection? It’s not you who is responsible for making me feel better about this thing. Very different.
I agree. It does make sense. When it comes to a point where a man, when he is not feeling good about himself and at the same time needs to make himself vulnerable to his partner, they are also, I would say, like the way you framed it, hyper-conscious about coming across as needy. Like, “Can you be a little bit more affectionate to me? I am not really feeling good about myself.” You can do that. You also run the risk of making yourself vulnerable in that sense. Your partner looking at you as someone who is potentially needy when they need to feel a bit safe and more protected, etc. You have that situation.
That is a fantastic note. This is where, again, the language, the framing, like, how do we approach this conversation? Every relationship is different. I do not know. It is hard to speak to a hypothetical. There are a lot of ways to do this. Actually, we will walk through the whole process so I can also talk about the different steps and how we use them to get to a place. If it is not, “I am feeling this way. I could use this X, Y, Z.”
Maybe that is not the language you have in your relationship. That is not the language that makes you feel empowered in it. It can be like, “Babe, what do we do that makes you feel really physically connected?” Makes you feel whatever it is that you are feeling less than. What is the thing like, “Do you like going to the gym together?” You can still ask. You can ask the questions. It is curiosity to get the information that you need that helps you show up more in that way. Does that make sense?
You are right. I want to ask you what it is like. You often hear, or you may see it within your larger, wider peer group, where the man becomes a man or woman, but starts becoming quite possessive. What is going on there in terms of?
Why Controlling Behavior And Possessiveness Destroy Trust
Avoidance. It is a tactic we use again to not actually be with the jealousy. If I can control my partner, this is the story I generally control. If I can create all these rules that they have to act within, then I can avoid this feeling of risk, of potential loss, of a very uncomfortable reality of life. That is actually shown to not only not build trust, not build security, but actually actively erode it. This idea of me controlling what you do is actually the opposite of what you are trying to do. Only build trust. Is probably one of the most uncomfortable truths that I have seen when it comes up in client sessions. You can only build trust with risk. You do not get one without the other.
If there is no risk, you are in a cage. There is no risk of leaving. The person actively choosing to be there is how you build trust. The person actively going through the repair process with you after conflict is what builds trust and intimacy. Without that, potentially without the mutual autonomy, the ability for either of you to leave at any time, it is not actually a choice to remain. You are not actually both choosing to be there. That thing is inherently what builds the trust between you two. It has the opposite effect. It is very common and normal to see that. It is generally related to talking about something suspicious or reactive.
Generally, that possessive behavior, that controlling behavior, is coming from more of a suspicious type of jealousy. We are building a case against what is happening. Maybe we have experienced infidelity in a previous relationship or a major rupture in a friendship or whatever that is that has given our brain pattern recognition for what untrustworthy behavior looks like. Now our brain, which is a master at pattern recognition and meaning-making, those are the two things that it is best at.
Now it is trained to look for those things. Whether or not they are actually happening in your current relationship, you are really good at finding them and then adding the meaning that they have met before. If you are not, again, in practice, what is my jealousy showing me? What is actually here for me? The difference between things that are actually occurring versus the case that I am building for them. Does that make sense?
Absolutely. I am going to ask you something.
Do it.
I have got a close friend who I guess is the test of the line. We talked a little bit about this before we started recording. There is a fine line between whether the jealousy is coming from insecurity within me or, actually, whether there is a genuine reason why you are jealous. Sometimes you are jealous because you are insecure. Sometimes you are jealous because something generally is not right.
I have experienced this personally as well, when your partner is behaving differently. She is hiding her phone. There is somebody at work she is talking about constantly. Something shifted. How do you distinguish between your intuition and your insecurity? It is like when you are feeling shit about yourself, because you are starting to have these emotions of jealousy. You do not know whether you should be beating yourself up for being, come on.
You should not be doing that regardless.
I am saying that you should be like you where your self-critic is actually becoming really sitting on your right shoulder there and just being really harsh and saying, what is wrong with you? Why are you acting so insecure? Where the reality of the situation is there is actually something going on there, which is untoward and, I guess, is not conducive to having a healthy relationship, like infidelity.
Whether you are a man or a woman, because it can happen either way. How do you recognize I am tripping? Even when you are being gaslit the other way, because that happens when they are, like, spinning you a yarn, because they want to get them. They do not want to confront it either. Now you are getting gassed on top of it. After you find out everything, you are like, “I should have listened to my intuition.” I thought it was me, mine. How do you know?
The question you are asking is how do we tell the difference between that insecurity?
That jealousy that is coming from an insecurity within you, the individual, or whether it is reasonably justified for you to be having that feeling of emotion, because there is something actually fucking going on and you realized it.
Some inconsistency maybe, words and actions, or first the relationship used to be what it is now, something actually going right. The short answer is we do not do that work in the activated moment. It is not.
It’s too hard, isn’t it?
The Jealousy Growth Method: Step-By-Step Grounding And Reflection
Absolutely. Your whole nervous system is in major activation. There is not going to be clarity from that place. You are going straight into the story, and how can we diagnose it from within the actual thing? This is what the growth method is for. Let us do a quick walkthrough. This is something we can use it for. G, first and foremost, ground. There is something physical happening in your body.
It is wildly uncomfortable, and you need to at least be with it for a moment to acknowledge what is happening. Where is it in your body? This is a process coming from, this whole system is inspired, like I said, from neuroscience out of a lab at Stanford. We have a mindfulness practice called RAIN, popularized by Tara Brach, that influences a number of different components that go into this process. Grounding is a part of mindfulness.
When I would say, “I would be feeling that in the gut.”
In the gut area. It is in your stomach. What does it feel like? What is it? Is it tight? Is it hot?
It feels like when you get stomach cramps, so it would be tightened up. It’s like you would get cramps, like stomach cramps within you. It would be tightening of the stomach and releasing the tightening.
We are in that. We are acknowledging this is what is happening in our body. That is actively taking us to a different part of our brain. We are coming out of the story where this is uncomfortable. This process is not to get rid of jealousy, but to turn jealousy into something else.
It is to recognize it.
It is to recognize it and expand your capacity to hold discomfort. That is, as a man, as a person, but especially as a man in the current world that we are in, to expand your capacity to hold discomfort, to be a well self-managed man. There is no more attractive, successful quality that you can develop in yourself. Jealousy is a powerful tool in that. We are in our bodies. It is our stomach. It is clenching. We are identifying where it is. We are going into a different part of our brain now because we are actually sitting in physical experience. We are not going off into story land.
There is no more attractive quality you can develop in yourself than to expand your capacity to hold discomfort and be a well-self-managed man. Share on XWe are in it. We are with it. We have identified where it lives. We have identified what it feels like. Now we are going to reflect. Again, is this something that is actually happening? Did I have to move something in my calendar? Was there actually an impact on my life in a measurable way? Did they say they were going to show up and they did not? What is the actual concrete factual information that we have? Again, not a story, not what I think and feel about the thing. What actually occurred? What are measurable, tangible things that I can reflect on and actually acknowledge occurred?
This is where we can get into the four different types of romantic jealousy that live under, whether it is self-bond, etc. We are out of the story activation. Again, we are into the body. We are looking at what is actually heard in life that may have been a part of this? Is it actual events or am I just extrapolating on things. We have got ground, growth, R, reflect, and then these do not necessarily have to be in order, and you do not necessarily have to do them all at once immediately. Ground is the most important one when you are in that activated state.
Just get into your body, get into a place where you can start managing the experience you are having versus avoiding it or throwing it into somebody else or getting into story land. We have got G, we have got R, we have got O. Open up is where we may be going to our partner. We do not have to start there. It is where we are engaging in the sociological component of jealousy. We are not just in a silo by ourselves trying to figure this out. Not suppressing it.
You are basically saying you need to open up and talk about it with someone that is going to either with your partner or with someone close to you who can sound bored with you and hold space for you and bounce with you and say “Whether you are tripping,” or maybe you do have some reasonable grounds there instead of workshop it with you.
It is not a diagnostic conversation, especially if we are talking to a therapist or a coach or somebody we are working with who specializes in this training. It is a slightly different conversation. If we are talking to our friends, have some discernment with who you are going to be talking to about this. If you have got a friend who is just like the drama of life, that is maybe not the person.
Someone is just to hold space and let you just unload.
We are not diagnosing. No one else is going to be diagnosing our experience for us. I am going to say the word that is going to make probably the majority of your audience cringe. Just in case the few of you who want journaling is a real thing, that can be really powerful. We do not have that.
I do that every day.
Fantastic. I love it. I made an assumption. Thank you for calling me out.
No, I do. I have asked all my kids to do it every day.
You get it. You understand the value. It can be a number of different things. You can journal to the journal. Can journal to the jealousy. You can journal to your partner and maybe never share it with them, or maybe share it with them. Maybe it is the way you collect your thoughts, or your journal to the version of yourself that has already moved through this, about what is happening. You are getting it out of, again, of story land, out of this spiral. We are putting it out there. Are still again, activating a different part of your brain. You want to handwrite if you can.
Witnessing Emotions, Timeouts, And Humanizing Perceived Rivals
Very different from just typing. If you cannot for whatever reason, voice notes are a great other option. Handwriting is number one for sure. Top of the game. You are opening it up. You are getting it out of just your siloed experience. Now we are in W. I can spell. Yes. W. Call it what it is. This is jealousy. You are not a jealous person. It is not a fixed point in time. You are experiencing jealousy, which is an emotion, an energy in motion. This is not something that you are going to live in for the rest of your life. It is like meditation.
You are basically saying you need to observe what is going on. You are not the emotion. You are not identifying with it. It is something you are experiencing, and you know, it is not you.
It might sound silly. Again, we have a culture where somebody can say, “I am a jealous person,” when that is not even a real thing. There is no such thing as a jealous person. You are a person who has the capacity to experience emotions.
It is something you experience. It is not something you are.

It is an important step because if you are not conscious of it, it could be very easy to get into that identification with the experience. We witness it. We know it is moving through us. We get to T, timeout. As I said, you do not have to go through this whole process immediately. You do not have to go through it all at once. Maybe you are in the O stage. You are actually talking to your partner, and you are both getting activated because neither of you has ever done this before, where you are actually learning to talk about jealousy and work with it. Jealousy is inherently trying to get you to have a conversation you have been avoiding, whatever it is.
Again, whether it is the relationship view, whatever it is, it is trying to get you to have some conversation that you have been avoiding. Let us say you are having it for the first time. You and your partner do not have the skill set. You are getting activated. They are getting defensive. That is making you upset. You notice that and you go, “Timeout. Let us take ten minutes.” It has to be a concrete amount of time. It cannot be, let us not talk about this now because there is no, that is not a time measurement. Take 10 minutes, 20 minutes. We are to go to our own space.
Maybe I am going to go into the journalling phase or whatever it is, or I am going to do some grounding work with my breath, whatever. We are going to go take care of ourselves. We are not just going to go start doing errands and to-dos. We are going to go. We are still in the conversation. Even if we are not together, we are going to be taking care of ourselves separately, and then we are going to come back together in ten minutes. It can look like you come back together in ten minutes and you are like, “I need another ten minutes.” Great, you just have to make sure it is a bracketed amount of time. It is specific.
“We cannot talk about this tonight because the kids, XYZ, tomorrow at 9:30 after my first meet,” whatever it is, specific and measurable time out. That can be for you if you have not even talked to your partner yet or whatever it is, “You know what, I cannot do this right now. I need to take a minute. How am I going to pour into myself? What feels good? I am going to the gym.” Whatever that is, it is about taking care of yourself in that time out. It is still a part of the process. It is not walking away from it. It is still very much about working with this. It can be just specifically about taking care of yourself and not continuing through yet.
That takes us to humanize. This is probably my favorite one to introduce. Jealousy will often involve a third party, either a rival or a perceived rival, what did you say? The person they talked about at work too much, that maybe that symbolizes something to you, they are more successful, they are more funny, whatever, whatever the story is, we are not worried about that right now. We are going to take that perceived rival, and we are going to make them a whole person.
They are not some Disney villain or some perfect archetype of whatever you feel you are not. We are going to picture them on the toilet. We are going to picture them pooping because there is a whole book about this. Everybody poops. They have it in common with you. They are, “I do not care how rich they are. I do not care how successful, how funny, how fit, they poop.” This is, “I now see in your face that you are. This is strange.”
It is not strange, everybody. I understand what you are trying to achieve. You are basically trying to put them at the most basic level. They are not all that.
Yes, exactly. This is a process we are dealing with very specific, different components of the very complex experience that we call jealousy, so that we are now actually actively in a relationship with it. This is the state where we get to start going, “What is here for me? What is the conversation I have not been having with myself, with my partner, with my colleague, whatever that is?” This is the information that we start getting. We know what jealousy is. Maybe it is a distrust. Maybe the relationship we are in, there has been a rupture in the past that we actually never repaired. Now I am seeing everything that comes up as possible. She is doing that again.
That is a conversation we need to have. “We actually have not gone through repair on this. What is that going to look like for us to actively do?” Not just like, “I forgive you. I will not do it again.” That is not a repair process. Repair. We can look at it as an apology. I teach what is called a three-part apology. Do name it, claim it, and reframe it. We acknowledge what has happened. There is, like, “We had an agreement that we were sexually exclusive.” I stepped outside of that agreement. That is what happened. That is what occurred. We are not adding judgment. We are not adding labels. We are not attacking. This is what happens.
We need to look at what is the environment of the relationship that we both have, did we enable this to happen? Was there a lack of affection, sex, or intimacy, or should I look at the whole picture? This is what happens. I did this, and this is the impact it had on you. I am going to claim it. This is what occurred. I am naming it. This is the impact it had on you, and I am going to own that. Again, we are not blaming. We are not characterizing what somebody is. I own that my choice had this impact on you. That is both directions. If we are in a relationship, I own that I have not been as affectionate or attentive or whatever it is.
Again, that is not making you responsible for the other person’s actions, absolutely not. We are each owning our contribution to what enabled this to occur. Then we are going to reframe it. This is what I am going to do. Is the part that I would say a majority of people skip. “This is what we are going to do in the future to make sure that environment is not happening again, that this does not happen again. We are going to have weekly date nights. We are going to do whatever that looks like for you.” You create that together. This is what happens.
The Three-Part Apology & Repairing Relationships After Betrayal
This is the impact it had on you and us. This is what I or we are going to do so it does not happen again in the future. That is a full repair process. That is a full apology. Missing any of those steps, repair has not taken place. It is not a button, especially if it is like infidelity, especially if it has been an ongoing affair or something like that. That is a massive rupture of trust that has to be built back. This is where we get into that uncomfortable reality around trust. I want to be really clear. This is not an overnight thing.
At some point, it is up to you to say, “I have decided that we have, we have gone through enough, you have shown me enough trustworthy behavior,” whatever that looks like, that I am now going to give you the power again to hurt me. Without that, there is no trust. I am willing to be at risk with you again because of what we have come through.
That is when you are giving trust again. Your partner on their own cannot rebuild trust. That is a mutually created thing. Again, that is not overnight, “We talked about it. We had a three-part apology. We created a new agreement. You should trust me now.” No, you build that over time. You are developing your discernment again. You are each showing up. We are not punishing each other for what has occurred. Not, and none of that. We are actively involved in that.
That is the hard part of what you have just said there, which is that both of the parties have got to come, like you said, there has been something like infidelity of any degree. Both parties have to agree that they are willing to reframe and move forward. However, with the caveat, which is what you said, you have to earn that trust back. That does not happen overnight. That can take years, and you have to be committed to it. There has to be a clear. On the other side, for it to work, the other needs to agree on not giving the other a hard time about it and making it difficult for them because then what is the then what is the point?
If there is no recipe, you cannot make anything like there has to be someone earning back your trust is not you holding over their head for X amount of time. “You did this.” You are not in a relationship creating something together. You are trying to protect the wound from ever happening again. What you are doing is building back the increased probability that it will not happen again. It is scar tissue. You do build back stronger. I will tell you that when you actually go through the repair process, when you build a relationship where you can have any conversation together, that is like the penultimate hashtag relationship goals.
When you can go, “I am noticing this in our relationship. We do not have intimacy. What is happening to you? It is impacting you this way. How are you experiencing it?” Versus, “You do not have sex with me enough. Give me enough non-sexual touch. You do not listen. That is not helpful.” I am noticing this. This is again. This is extrapolated out of this jealousy practice. That is why I say jealousy is such a valuable experience in a relationship because you are getting to practice that process. You are getting to practice holding discomfort as an empowered man in a relationship, which is inherently vulnerable. Vulnerability is uncomfortable.
Vulnerability is uncomfortable, but there is no way around it—you don't get intimacy without vulnerability. Share on XThere is no way around it. You do not get intimacy without vulnerability. Vulnerability is basically risk, which is inherently uncomfortable. Have you developed your discernment enough to decide, these are the types of people. This is the person I am going to give the most power to? Have you developed discernment so you trust your decision-making because that is also what gets ruptured? When we are experiencing something like infidelity. “Did I make a good decision? How can I trust myself?” You are not just building trust with your partner again.
You are also rebuilding trust with yourself. This has to be an active recipe. There have to be ways that you are doing that, not just like, “Time, how are we showing up differently? What am I going to do for myself so that I am learning how to trust that discernment again? What are we doing together?” We are creating a different environment that will not enable that to happen again. What is she doing on her own to look at her contribution there and how she can? This is a relationship. This is what we agree to do together in a relationship.
Navigating Modern Social Media Triggers And Digital Exposure
We cannot talk about the elephant in the room with jealousy. I think about myself. I have got an incredible relationship with my partner, and both of us are extremely inactive on social media. We may look at things that might be going on, but you would not see a like, a comment, a post, none of that. Neither of us has ever really been into that. I have got my own reasons. In our modern world, I have to accept that, particularly with younger generations, it is very much a part of the way they communicate and the way they interact with the world, etc.
I can try to guide my kids as best as possible as to all the risks and the risk-reward payoff in the social media world. The bottom line is you cannot really push up against a tsunami. You just have to let things happen as they do. Hopefully, give them the best tools possible to make them aware of what they are in for. Having said that, I can understand how, when it comes to the subject of jealousy within relationships, this will be amplified exponentially when it comes to social media.
When you have things like Instagram, dating apps, 25 years ago, your partner did not walk around with thousands of potential romantic competitors in her pocket. Fucking, that just did not exist. I can think about some women that are close to my world that I am aware of, one hell of a lot that operate in relationships, but they are constantly looking for attention externally via these situations. You say with younger women, but even women of my own peer group, that they are looking for validation, external validation, and DMs.
There are exes out there, people they went to school with, people she potentially slept with in the past. Has technology fundamentally increased the amount of jealousy we are expected to manage? Is liking someone’s photo harmless? I am fortunate that I have not introduced those additional variables into the relationship, which can affect it. Just in general, because of the ease of communication, whether it is WhatsApp, Facebook, whatever, you are going to get a lot of likes. If I think about my partner, we are going to get inbound messages from either people from the past or someone that you met.
They are so easily contactable. They do not have to ask for your number. They can simply say, “You want Instagram?” You are publicly exposed, and it is a lot easier for many people to get in touch with you. How does one deal with all of that? Does it make sense that I am jealous if my partner liked a photo of another guy or vice versa? Should I be jealous if someone’s started reaching out to your partner and it could, and I am assuming a lot of it is harmless, but not all of it is?
I am so glad to bring in a side.
There is a lot there. I have just thrown in a mix there, but I actually find it very intriguing. I have had partners in the past who are very active. They are very active. I find it, I do not know how to rationalise if you are with, like, what you see is you will see a couple in a healthy relationship, in a very healthy, what looks like a romantic relationship. I will say, in this example, the woman is constantly posting herself out there to the world, obviously wanting to show how she thinks she is looking good, but she is constantly posting herself out there. I am wondering if you are in a relationship with someone.
Thankfully, I am not in a relationship with someone who is like that. If I were, are you trying to entice fellow suitors to be peacocking, or are you looking for attention to make yourself feel better? How should I feel about that situation? I am the partner. How am I engaging with my partner and saying that does not make me feel very good? Why do you find it necessary to put yourself out there in that sense, particularly if it is not with me in the photos? Often, whether it is the man or the woman, I would say there is a lot more going on with women in that sense, where they are literally in a relationship but posting themselves. Just like, “Look at me. Don’t I look fabulous?”
Retroactive Jealousy, Digital Curation, And ‘Peacocking’ Online
There is a lot in what you just presented. I want to try and touch as many of the points as possible. When we are looking at the digital world, the digital landscape, there is actually, what is the actual term? It is like digitally induced jealousy or something like that, specifically around the outer layer of digital life as a trigger.
There is a condition already.
Not a diagnosis like, what is this new thing? There is a newer area of jealousy under study called retroactive jealousy. It is somewhat related here.
You can go and look at their faces. “What about these?”
Exactly. Have a previous partner where, you know, I am sure your previous sex life is so much better. Like, “I am going to just doomscroll at 3:00 AM through all your access.” We have access to your point that we have never had before. The imaginary monster is still scarier, but now we have the actual evidence that we can build if we want to have, like, how much better their previous partnerships or whatever were.
I like to say we are getting the closing night performance compared to our backstage. Other people’s closing night performance. We are getting the curated feed of all of what they determined to be the best parts of their life, not their whole life. We go into H again. We are going to humanize them. What are all the parts we are not seeing? First and foremost, we are going to interrupt that pattern. This is the curated version. What does their bathroom look like? Let us get real.
What does their toilet bowl look like? You are like straightening a toilet bowl.
How is their fiber intake? Let us just, let us make them people first and foremost. That is, retroactive jealousy is one of the types that you are really fixated on in the past. The trigger is something you cannot actually do anything about in real time because it has already happened. You cannot change your partner’s previous sex life.
I am talking about, forget about the past. I am talking about in real time.
Let us bring it in. This digital layer that we have. Now we can have the photographic “evidence” and all that. This peacocking, as you call it. We have to talk about something that is really important when we are talking about jealousy, especially in this context. The difference between boundaries, rules, and agreements. Boundaries are how I take care of myself. They do not actually have anything to do with other people. I do not engage with this exchange. This is what I do in the event that someone is speaking to me in a disrespectful way that I do not accept.
This is how I take care of myself. A rule is me trying to control somebody else’s behavior to avoid whatever the thing is, instead of actually just taking care of myself. An agreement is something, basically, a boundary for the relationship that we create together. Let us use the example that you are talking about, We are deciding that our partner’s peacocking. They are all over the internet, sexy photos, that is. I am going to assume that this was already taking place before you guys met. They have had an online presence. This did not start when you got together. This is a two different, somewhat different conversation.
Either way, let us say, like, in today’s world, you get together with someone and in their previous behavior, they were always someone who posted online, they were active or whatever, and they are with you now, and they continue to do so. You are just saying the behavior has not changed, like a new behavior.
You are noticing it is bringing up some uncomfortable feelings in yourself.
You are also questioning it, and obviously it is not the same, but it is indicative. It is almost like being with someone, forming a serious relationship with someone, but staying on the dating apps. Not as extreme. If you are in a relationship, I am still trying to understand what is the motivation for wanting to continue to put yourself out there and post yourself all the time to “Look at me, l look fabulous.” What would you be doing that for?
The most comfortable truth if we do not have a conversation again out of curiosity? I am curious what you get out of this. “I know you were doing it before, and I like that you are hot. That is why I am here. It works.” For me, it feels like this. What is it for you? Now you are doing this because of that. Do not get it.
It’s very hard. It becomes a very challenging conversation, I think, because I will tell you why. From the man’s perspective, let us say in this situation, from the man’s perspective, you do not want to be the possessive trying to be the controlling party. At the same time, there is clearly a difference in values or belief systems going on there. If you think, “No, it is really cool.” It actually makes me feel good about whatever, and you do not realise what is going on. I just see that as a disconnect.
Boundaries Vs. Rules Vs. Agreements: Asking Curious Questions
Potentially. This is the importance of boundaries and control. Dating somebody with the intention of them changing you, or the assumption that they are going to do X, Y, Z if you have never even talked about it, is setting yourself up for failure. You do not ever get to tell somebody else what they can and cannot do. I will use, she posts a bunch of photos. She loves her bikinis, and she loves to post herself in bikinis. Who knows why, but she posts a lot of photos of herself in bikinis. She was doing that before you met. She is continuing to do that.
You do not get to say, “Now that we are together, you do not get to wear bikinis.” You do get to decide if you want to be with somebody who posts bikini pictures of themselves. That is a boundary. Do I want to be in a relationship? They are not a bad person. You do not get to assign blame, judgment, anything like that. You have this information, whether you had it or not before. You have it now. Is this something you want to engage with? It is not an ultimatum. I am breaking up with you unless you do this.
You can express your opinion about it.
I would not even start.
You would say, “I am curious. Why do you do this?”
I have noticed that, as you look, first of all, we are going to introduce the shit sandwich. I did not point to that phrase, but it is a powerful tool. I know there is discomfort. We are going to put the meat of that discomfort in the middle, but we are going to start with “Babe, you look so hot in these photos. You look amazing,” whatever that is. First and foremost, whatever is true and feels really nice.
Smoke blowing.
God, no, like that thought asked whatever it is. We are going to, we are going to share that positive feedback. We are going to get into the question. “I am really curious. What do you get out of that? What does it make you feel like? Why do you like doing that?” You do not know. I do not care how long you have been together. You will never know your partner inside and out ever. I do not care if you have been married for 50 years.
You are right.
We finish each other’s sentences, which is called interrupting. Get curious. That is the most powerful tool you can have in being comfortable with being uncomfortable, getting curious. We end again with, like, “I love it. Can I take some photos sometimes?” Maybe you just want to be involved in the process so you feel like you are a part of it. What is the actual thing that is being brought up? Are you feeling disconnected from them in that experience?
Great. Can we make it a shared experience? Can we take some beach photos together? When you get curious, and you are understanding the value system for them now, you can actually start seeing where they are coming from. It may not actually be a value discrepancy. You may be assigning meaning that is not there for them. Maybe they had no idea. If they are like an Instagram model or whatever like that, they could assume that is super boring to you, and you do not want to be a part of that.
They do not want to look for it in you with how much content they have to shoot all the time. It is going to be such a gift, and you are like, “Actually, I just want to be involved. You look so great. If I learn how to shoot, or whatever that is now, it has actually become an opportunity for you guys to get closer. Do not assume you know why. Do not assume. Get curious.
I like it. We could talk a little.
You opened up a whole second episode of that.
Funny, cause you said before, I was like, “I think we can fill a program on jealousy.” You are like, “I just want to warn you, before this gets a lot further and it can really, it can keep going.”
The reason I am writing a book.
You are right. We have hit the hour. There is so much more to talk about. We might have to do a second section because I did want to talk. There are a whole lot of other things I want to talk to you about, particularly around monogamy and polyamory. The trust after betrayal or all those things. We will have to do part two at some stage.
I will do a teaser for that, though. Research shows us, as we said before, that there is no difference in frequency or intensity of jealousy when it comes to secure or insecure. There is also no difference between monogamous and non-monogamous. There is no relationship structure that prevents jealousy, and also preventing jealousy should not be the goal. It is just an emotion. We can use that to segue into a future episode.
Rapid-Fire Insights & Sitting With Discomfort As A Superpower
Super interesting. Before we go though, I always ask my guests five rapid-fire questions. I have got to, I have got to get these out of you.
Let us go.
Who would you like to say sorry to, given the chance?
This is where you are trying to get your guests to cry. Got it. Nice. Both of my grandmothers, but especially my dad’s mom. I wish I had asked more questions. I wish I had asked her more questions about her and her life and her thoughts and her perspective. I really do.
What are you proud of being or doing in your life?
I have had quite the last 18 or 20 months have been a doozy. I am quite proud of myself for moving through the way that I have, but concretely, I am really proud of myself for writing a book. I have wanted to write a book since I was a kid. I definitely did not think it was going to be a book about jealousy and how important it is. I am really proud of myself for sitting down and doing this. This is a really important knowledge base that I want the world to have.
Amazing. When did you receive kindness while needing it most, but expecting at least?
In a specific moment. I will just say it is actually such a wonderful relationship, a life partnership. Earlier in our relationship, I would say I was having quite a dark chapter, just some really hard stuff. All at once, and just not the best version of myself, not a pretty internal experience. I am very used to just, like, “Let me just take care of that. You do not need to see any of that.” He was actually like, “No, I want to know what is happening for you.” She was like, “Are you sure?” “I am all right.
I am going to share it with you.” My lived experience was telling me, “I am going to do it.” This is the moment where he is like, “Too much. This is not it,” or reacting, making, taking it personally, or whatever other version. This man was just present with me. This is what I am talking about. As we talked about earlier in our conversation, we do not want to look needy or whatever. Taking care of yourself and asking for the support you need is not needy.
Making somebody else responsible for your state is needy. It’s very different. I have gotten to a place in my life where it was not up to him to make me feel better. He knows that he is a well self-managed man. That does not mean he is to run away from the discomfort. He wants to be in it with me, no flinching, nothing. I was just so gracious and met me with such compassion, but also firmness, very logic-based, which is very powerful.
It was my kind of kindness that is like accountability with grace, with compassion, but like, “I am hearing this and seeing this. Let us go from there.” Not like, “No, everything is by yourself.” That does not help. That is not kindness to me. That is just not much. The kindness to me was the accountability, the reflection, the steady stability, the presence with me in that moment. It was such a foundational experience in our relationship that I will be forever grateful for it.
Amazing. That was awesome. What did your mother or father teach you that you frequently remind yourself of?
Not a lot. My dad will give him this.
Not a lot. I am surprised.
I learned a lot about what I do not want in my life. I do not have animosity. My parents did the best that they could with what they had. It was not helpful in a lot of ways. I am who I am now, and it turned out pretty alright. Even that was a part of that process. I am grateful for that. My dad did, he likes to say “This too shall pass,” which has been something he did not coin the term, but it is definitely something he brought up and stayed with me and as witness, this too shall pass. This is jealousy.
It is moving through like it is, whether it is good or bad. It really helps you be able to appreciate that joy when it is there. That you can be grateful for whatever is happening. In those tougher moments, this is not forever. I can get through this. I have gotten through it before. Just the temporary nature of life enables you to be so grateful for the gifts that you do have, the beautiful partnerships you have in your life. It also gives you the resilience and the strength to get through when things just are not working out.
Last one. What is your superpower?
I love jealousy. Honestly, if you can sit in discomfort, you become unstoppable in life. You are so powerful. I have to say, being able to sit with discomfort.
If you can sit in discomfort, you become unstoppable in life. Bravery doesn't exist without fear, and resilience doesn't exist without discomfort. Share on XIt is effectively, you could replace that with resilience effectively. You are saying that when you are talking about sitting with the discomfort, it is the grit and the resilience to be able to move through the discomfort and come out the other end and be all okay.
It is like bravery does not exist without fear. Resilience does not exist without that discomfort, and all of that too. It is hard to remember that in the moment, but reflecting on it, yeah, bravery, resilience for sure.
Ally, thank you. I am going to have to get you back on. I am sorry.
I am so sorry. Another wonderful conversation.
We are going to do it again. We will do part two, think, on the relationship side, and one of the big ones is, I think, how to come back from the betrayal with the jealousy. How does one come to that?
In whatever kind of relationship you are in. Whether you are monogamous or non monogamous, you can be cheated on. It’s not about lying. It is about deceit far more than it is about what you are doing with somebody else.
Thank you.
Wonderful. Thank you. I do want to share with your audience really quickly because we were talking specifically about jealousy today. As we said, this is a robust topic. You are going to deal with it, if you have not yet, at some point in your life. What kind am I dealing with? What value can I get out of it? If this conversation is really like bringing something up for you, I created a free quiz to help people really understand which type of romantic jealousy they are dealing with right now or most frequently or maybe their partner is dealing with.
You’ve got to put it in the bio. It is going to be in the bio.
Free quiz for you, the JealousyQuiz.com.
The bio will have the quiz in there and also have some information about your book where they can buy your book.
Thank you so much.
Thank you.
Important Links
- Ally Iseman
- Ally Iseman on LinkedIn
- Ally Iseman on Facebook
- Ally Iseman on Instagram
- The Continuum Concept
- Jealousy Quiz
About Ally Iseman
ALLY ISEMAN, CRC is an award-winning creator, author, internationally Certified Relationship Coach and NCSF-registered Kink Aware Professional who specializes in modern relationship design, unlocking erotic jealousy, and consent and communication. She speaks on stages and screens of all sizes, and is a featured culture commentator and subject matter expert who has been featured in The New York Times, LADbible, Cosmopolitan, AskMen, and more. Ally works with couples and individuals all over the world who are at transition points in their dating and relation-trips. Whether they want to open their relationship to include more people, explore play parties together, or just open up more authentically to each other about their kinks and curiosities, Ally helps them open up without breaking up. She is based in Los Angeles and London.